← NewsAll
Catholic newspaper says JD Vance's defense of ICE shooting is a 'moral stain'.
Summary
The National Catholic Reporter published an op-ed criticizing Vice President JD Vance for defending the fatal shooting of Renee Nicole Good by an ICE officer and called his comments a 'moral stain' on Catholic witness.
Content
A Catholic news outlet published a strong op-ed responding to Vice President JD Vance's public defense of a fatal shooting by a federal immigration officer. The piece, written by National Catholic Reporter digital editor John Grosso, criticized Vance's language and invoked religious concerns about his public statements. Vance, a Catholic convert, publicly described the victim as a "deranged leftist" and linked her to broader political activity. The administration defended the officer involved while news reports and analyses have reported details that complicate that account.
Key reported points:
- The National Catholic Reporter published an op-ed by John Grosso condemning Vice President JD Vance's public defense of the fatal shooting of Renee Nicole Good.
- Vance described the victim in strongly political terms on social media as he defended the officer's actions.
- Administration officials, including President Donald Trump, characterized the incident as self-defense; video analyses reported by news outlets found the officer was not in the SUV's path when he fired.
- The op-ed called Vance's comments a "moral stain" on the collective witness of the Catholic faith and said his approach to Catholicism appeared politicized, urging prayer for a conversion of heart.
Summary:
The op-ed frames Vance's defense of the shooting as at odds with the Catholic witness and criticizes the use of faith as a political tool. Undetermined at this time.
