Assisted Suicide Debate: Admiral Brian Christine Urges a Culture of Care

Admiral Brian Christine, MD, writing as Assistant Secretary for Health at HHS, opposes assisted suicide and calls for greater investment in palliative, hospice, and mental health services; the article notes Illinois recently legalized assisted suicide and New York’s governor has pledged to sign a Medical Aid in Dying bill.

Illinois recently moved to legalize assisted suicide and New York’s governor has pledged to sign a Medical Aid in Dying bill. Admiral Brian Christine, MD, speaking in his role at the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, opposes assisted suicide and frames the issue as one of human dignity. He urges greater investment in palliative and hospice care, expanded mental health services, and stronger support for patients, families, and caregivers. The piece also cites data from jurisdictions with legalized aid-in-dying to describe why people seek it. Key reported facts: - In December, Illinois’ governor signed a bill legalizing assisted suicide, according to the article. - New York Governor Kathy Hochul has said she will sign the state’s Medical Aid in Dying Act; if signed, New York would become the thirteenth state. - The article cites Canadian government reports saying more than 80 percent of MAiD recipients reported loss of independence and about 45 percent reported not wanting to be a burden; Oregon data for 2024 showed 89 percent cited loss of autonomy and 42 percent cited concern about burdening family. - Admiral Brian Christine, as Assistant Secretary for Health, states that assisted suicide violates human dignity and recommends expanded palliative care, hospice, mental health services, and support for caregivers. Summary: Admiral Brian Christine presents HHS opposition to assisted suicide and advocates for a renewed focus on care and supports for vulnerable patients. Illinois has legalized assisted suicide and Governor Hochul has indicated she will sign New York’s Medical Aid in Dying Act; the next procedural step reported is the governor’s signature.